Agentic SEO Tools
All posts
By Agentic SEO Tools Teamalternatives

Otterly.AI alternatives that act on AI search, scored feature by feature (2026)

Otterly.AI tracks and advises but lists no publishing. Five alternatives scored on monitor, optimize, publish and measure, with plan-level gaps checked November 2026.

Otterly.AI is where a lot of teams start with AI search. The Lite plan on its pricing page is €29 a month, the trial needs no credit card, every plan has unlimited team members and unlimited countries and languages, and prompts are checked daily. If the job is to show a manager that ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews name competitors more often than your brand, it does that job for very little money.

This site scores tools on what happens after that chart. We ask four questions of every platform. Does it monitor? Does it tell you what to fix? Does it make the fix? Does it measure whether the fix worked? On those terms Otterly is a monitor with a decent advice layer. Its Recommendations (three a week on Lite, unlimited from Standard) and its Content Audit point at what to change. Content generation, CMS publishing and visitor analytics are not listed on Otterly's pricing or product pages (checked November 2026). Its Agent Analytics crawler data starts on Standard at €189, and Otterly's own llms.txt still describes it as a closed beta.

The plan structure is the other reason teams look around. Lite covers 15 search prompts on four engines: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot. Gemini, Google AI Mode and Claude are add-ons on every plan, from €9 a month on Lite up to €439 for Claude on Premium, and extra prompt packs (100 for €99 a month) are only sold on Standard and Premium. The alternatives below each do more of the work themselves, or at least more of the measuring. AthenaHQ and Scrunch AI are the names that usually land on the shortlist next to Otterly.AI. Promptwatch goes first.

Otterly.AI pricing page with monthly plans: Lite at €29 with 15 search prompts, Standard at €189 with 100, Premium at €489 with 400, and a custom Enterprise plan from 1,000 search prompts Otterly.AI's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026. Prices shown in euros for a visitor in the Netherlands.

How we score: monitor, optimize, publish, measure

Each stage gets 0 to 3 points, based on the vendor's own pricing and product pages as captured November 6 to 8, 2026:

  • 0 means the capability is not listed on the vendor's pages.
  • 1 means partial, in beta, or only on Enterprise or in a separate product.
  • 2 means it is on a self-serve plan, with a limit a working program will hit.
  • 3 means it is on a self-serve plan at full depth.

We score each tool's best self-serve plan and name that plan in the text. The ranking puts the two acting stages, optimize and publish, ahead of the other two, because a tool that only reports leaves the work with you.

ToolMonitorOptimizePublishMeasureActing score (optimize + publish)
Promptwatch33336
AthenaHQ23114
Scrunch AI22113
LLM Pulse12123
Semrush AI Toolkit21112
Otterly.AI (reference)22012

Scrunch AI and LLM Pulse tie on every total. Scrunch takes the higher spot on a tie-break: its Agent Experience Platform changes what AI agents are served from your site, which is an action rather than a report. It sits on Enterprise, so it earns no points.

Quick verdict

  • Promptwatch is the one to test first. It is the only tool here that scores on all four stages on self-serve plans: it writes and publishes to WordPress, Webflow or Framer, then shows whether the page was crawled, cited and clicked.
  • AthenaHQ suits teams that want an action queue to work through and can budget in credits.
  • Scrunch AI suits brands that want bot traffic and basic content drafts on one $250 plan.
  • LLM Pulse suits small budgets that can live with weekly data and want conversion tracking.
  • Semrush AI Toolkit suits teams that already depend on Semrush's keyword and backlink data.

Otterly.AI alternatives at a glance

ToolBest forStarting priceWhat it doesn't list
PromptwatchTeams that want one loop from prompt to published page$95/mo (Essential), 7-day free trialEssential has no crawler logs or AEO articles; the automated Content Agent starts on Business ($579/mo); HIPAA not listed
AthenaHQTeams that will work an action queueFree Essential tier; Starter $295/moAI crawler logs, an MCP server and query fan-outs not listed; API is a paid add-on on Starter
Scrunch AIBrands testing agent-facing pagesCore $250/mo, 7-day free trialCMS publishing and AI-referred conversions not listed; Claude, Gemini and AI Mode are Enterprise only
LLM PulseSmall teams on a tight budget€49/mo (Starter, weekly tracking)CMS publishing and personas not listed; crawler logs start on Scale (€299/mo)
Semrush AI ToolkitTeams already using Semrush for SEO$99/mo per domain (Base, billed annually)Query fan-outs, personas and ads tracking not listed; crawler log analysis is Enterprise AIO only
Otterly.AI (reference)A first AI visibility baseline€29/mo (Lite)Content generation, CMS publishing and visitor analytics not listed; Gemini, AI Mode and Claude cost extra

Sources: each vendor's pricing page captured November 6, 2026, plus product pages and llms.txt files fetched November 8, 2026. Euro prices are what those pages showed a visitor in the Netherlands, and Semrush's Base price is from its AI pricing page as fetched. Promptwatch facts come from its llms.txt, ai-agent-instructions and pricing pages, re-checked November 4, 2026.

1. Promptwatch: all four stages on self-serve plans

Promptwatch scores 3 on every stage, and each Otterly gap maps to a named feature with a plan attached.

Publishing is the biggest difference. Professional ($245 a month) includes 5 AEO articles a month, written from a brief that pulls in your branding, Google results, news, YouTube transcripts and up to five competitor URLs. The writer picks internal links before it drafts, favoring pages with many Search Console impressions and few clicks. Business ($579) adds the automated Content Agent, which plans, writes and publishes against visibility gaps on a publishing calendar with a monthly budget. A review inbox lets you approve, edit or decline each piece, or you can switch it to fully automated mode. Output goes to WordPress through the official plugin, to Webflow or to Framer, as a draft or live. We covered how to set those approvals up in our guide to review inboxes and rollback.

Promptwatch Content Agents page with a content calendar of published articles beside a Content Agent queue of suggested pieces with Generate and Publish buttons Promptwatch's Content Agents page, captured November 8, 2026.

Measurement comes next. Visitor analytics is on every plan, from 200K events on Essential, and counts AI-referred visits and conversions through a script, a GTM template or the WordPress plugin. Agent Analytics, from Professional, logs AI crawler visits checked against each operator's published IP ranges, so a bot faking GPTBot's user agent is filtered out. It shows a citation rate per page and explains crawl errors. That tells you whether a page failed because the bot never read it, or because it read the page and cited someone else. Search Insights adds Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster clicks on every brand plan.

Optimization runs through the Action Board. A Discovery agent investigates on a weekly schedule and suggests up to five evidence-backed actions per run, with assignees and comments. Content Refresh proposes diff-style edits to pages you already have, and Fact Check (Business, Agency Scale and Enterprise) tests a claim AI makes about you against pages crawled from your own site. Weekly site audits with 21 checks are on every plan, including an internal linking map that flags orphan pages.

Promptwatch site health internal linking map grouping pages by URL path, with orphan pages marked red and pages with one or two inlinks marked orange Promptwatch site health linking map, from the Promptwatch changelog. Example project data.

Monitoring covers the rest. Every paid plan can track any of the supported engines with no per-engine surcharge. Business adds tracking every 12, 6 or 1 hours, state and city tracking, and coordinate-level targeting. Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn and Instagram citation reports, Page Tracker for your own or a competitor's URL, and personas are part of the platform, and seats are unlimited on every paid plan.

The weak spots are real. Essential at $95 has no crawler logs and no AEO articles, so at Otterly's price range Promptwatch is a monitoring and traffic tool, not a publisher. Ads Radar and ChatGPT Shopping start on Business, while Otterly lists ads and shopping tracking without naming a plan. The trial is 7 days, on monthly billing, across all six self-serve plans.

2. AthenaHQ: the strongest action queue, metered in credits

AthenaHQ scores 3 on optimize. Starter ($295 a month) includes on-page and off-page actions, a content optimization agent, "self-learning content improvement" and an Action Center that prioritizes opportunities. It lists 11 models on Starter, among them Gemini, Claude, Google AI Mode, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral, and users are unlimited on every plan. The free Essential tier, with 300 credits on five engines and the Athena AI agent, is a genuine way to try it before paying.

AthenaHQ pricing page showing a free Essential tier with a $25 credit, Starter at $295 a month with visibility across 11 models, and a custom Enterprise plan with the Athena Citation Engine AthenaHQ's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.

Publishing is where it drops to 1. AthenaHQ's home page says its Shopify integration lets you publish AEO-optimized content, and Webflow and Framer integrations are listed without saying they publish. The autonomous content agents in the Athena Citation Engine are Enterprise only. Measurement also scores 1: GA4 and Search Console integrations connect visibility to traffic, but AI crawler logs are not listed on AthenaHQ's pricing or product pages (checked November 2026). Neither is an MCP server, and the API is a paid add-on on Starter.

Then there are the credits. One credit is one AI response, and Starter includes 3,600 a month, so thirty prompts on four engines run every day would use all of it. Prompts are unlimited in name, but the credits decide how many you can run, and extra credits are priced on request.

3. Scrunch AI: bot traffic and drafts on one plan

Scrunch AI Core costs $250 a month for 125 unique prompts, 5,000 responses, five site audits, one brand workspace, one country, one persona and five user licenses, with a 7-day free trial. Core also includes AI agent and bot traffic, split into training, indexing and retrieval bots. "Basic" content generation finds prompts no page of yours answers and drafts on-brand content for them. Insights, Recommendations and Signals flag changes and what to do about them, and Page Optimizations are capped at one a month.

Scrunch pricing page showing Core at $250 a month with 125 unique prompts, 5,000 responses, 5 site audits, 1 brand workspace and 5 user licenses, next to an Enterprise plan that adds AXP Scrunch's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.

The limits matter for a team leaving Otterly. Core tracks four LLMs (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Copilot), the same base set Otterly includes. Claude, Gemini, Meta AI, Google AI Mode and Grok are Enterprise only, and so are MCP access, the API and Looker Studio. CMS publishing and AI-referred conversions are not listed, and the agent traffic page doesn't list IP verification or a crawl-to-citation link. Five licenses is also fewer than Otterly's unlimited team members. The Agent Experience Platform, which serves AI-optimized versions of your pages to agents without changing what people see, is the most interesting action on this list after Promptwatch's publishing. It is Enterprise only. Scrunch is now a Sitecore company, according to its llms.txt.

4. LLM Pulse: conversions on a small budget, weekly by default

LLM Pulse has the lowest paid entry among the alternatives. Starter is €49 a month (€40.83 billed annually) for 50 prompts, one project and five engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, AI Overviews and Gemini. That price buys weekly tracking. Daily tracking is sold as separate plans with no trial, which is why monitoring scores 1. The weekly plans come with a 14-day free trial, a week longer than Promptwatch's.

Measurement scores 2, the best here after Promptwatch. AI traffic analytics with sessions, conversions and revenue by AI source starts on Growth (€99), and server-log crawler data from Cloudflare, Vercel, Fastly, CloudFront and others starts on Scale (€299). GEO Writer drafts content, three tasks a month on Starter and 15 on Scale, and Recommendations give prioritized, evidence-based actions. CMS publishing is not listed, so the work stops at a draft. Claude is an add-on (€25 a month on weekly Starter), the REST API starts on Scale, and an MCP server with about 140 tools is on every plan.

5. Semrush AI Toolkit: the SEO suite's AI layer

Semrush AI Toolkit makes sense when your team already works in Semrush. The strength is the classic SEO data underneath: Semrush cites 28B+ keywords and 43T+ backlinks, plus rank tracking, which Promptwatch doesn't offer at that scale. The AI Visibility Toolkit Base plan is $99 a month per domain, billed annually, for 25 custom prompts tracked daily on ChatGPT, Google AI, Gemini and Perplexity. It adds 300 instant AI visibility reports a day for any domain, which is handy for competitor research without any prompt setup.

For an acting workflow it scores low. Content generation lives in the separate Content Toolkit, and the pages don't say which CMSs its publishing integrations cover. Recommendations are listed, but no task board is described. Crawler log analysis and GA4 or Adobe conversion data are on Enterprise AIO only, and Search Console data comes through a Report add-on (€9.59 a month on the captured euro page). Query fan-outs, personas and ads tracking are not listed, and extra users start at €43 a month.

Feature gaps: what each tool lists

CapabilityPromptwatchOtterly.AIAthenaHQScrunch AILLM Pulse
Engines without per-engine feesYes, any supported engine on every paid plan4 base; AI Mode, Gemini, Claude are add-onsYes, 11 models on Starter4 on Core; 5 more Enterprise only5; others are add-ons from €8/mo
Tracking faster than dailyEvery 12, 6 or 1 hours (Business)DailyNot listedNot listedDaily, on separate plans
PersonasYes, with persona stackingNot listedEnterprise only1 on CoreNot listed
State, city or coordinate targetingState/city on Business and agency plans; coordinates on Business and Agency ScaleNot listedNot listedNot listedNot listed
Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn, Instagram citation reportsYes, all fourNot listedNot listedPartial ("Social" segment)YouTube and Reddit from Growth
Track a chosen URL, incl. a competitor'sPage TrackerNot listedNot listedPartial (own URLs)Partial (audit only)
AI crawler logsFrom ProfessionalStandard and up (closed beta)Not listedCoreScale and up
IP-verified bots, crawl-to-citation rateYesNot listedNot listedPartial (bot types only)Partial (per-URL correlation)
AI-referred visits and conversionsEvery planNot listedPartial (GA4)Not listedGrowth and up
Search Console and Bing dataEvery brand planNot listedPartial (Search Console)Not listedSearch Console, plan not stated
Fact check against your own pagesBusiness, Agency Scale, EnterpriseNot listedEnterprise onlyNot listedNot listed
In-app agent over your dataAgent Chat, every planNot listed (MCP from Standard)Yes, from the free tierPartial (MCP on Enterprise)Partial (from Growth)
Article generationAEO articles from ProfessionalNot listed (briefs only)Partial (optimization agent; autonomous agents on Enterprise)Basic on CoreGEO Writer, 3 tasks/mo on Starter
CMS publishing, scheduledWordPress, Webflow, Framer; scheduled Content Agent on BusinessNot listedPartial (Shopify)Not listedNot listed

Which missing rows hurt depends on who does the work. An in-house content team feels the last two rows most. With Otterly, every recommendation becomes a ticket for a writer, and nobody connects the published page back to the prompt that triggered it. An agency reporting to clients feels the measurement rows: conversions and Search Console data are what a client reads, and Otterly lists neither. Multi-location brands hit the location row, where only Promptwatch lists anything below country level. Regulated or fast-moving categories, where a wrong claim in an AI answer costs real money, should look at the fact-check row, where Promptwatch's version runs on a self-serve plan and AthenaHQ's is Enterprise only.

Who should pick which

  • You want the tool to write, publish, and then prove the page worked: Promptwatch. Choose Business for the scheduled Content Agent, or Professional if 5 articles a month plus crawler logs covers your output.
  • You want an action list your team works through and credits don't worry you: AthenaHQ.
  • You want bot traffic and draft content on one plan around $250, and four engines are enough: Scrunch AI.
  • You need conversion data cheaply and weekly checks are fine: LLM Pulse on Growth.
  • You buy SEO data first and AI visibility second: Semrush AI Toolkit.
  • Stay on Otterly.AI if your prompt list is short, the four base engines cover your market, and someone on the team already turns the recommendations into pages by hand. A tracker that answers your question doesn't need replacing.

Our recommendation

Teams leave Otterly once the report stops being the hard part. Somebody still has to write the page and publish it, then check whether AI crawlers read it and buyers clicked through. Promptwatch keeps those steps in one project. AEO articles draft against a tracked prompt and publish to your CMS, Agent Analytics shows the crawl, citation analytics and Page Tracker show the citation, and visitor analytics shows the conversion. Start the 7-day free trial on Professional with your current Otterly prompt list, publish one AEO article to WordPress, Webflow or Framer, and follow it through Agent Analytics for the week. For every row side by side, read Promptwatch vs Otterly.AI.

FAQ

Does Otterly.AI publish content?

Not on the evidence we have. Content generation and CMS publishing are not listed on Otterly's pricing or product pages (checked November 2026). Its Content Audit produces content briefs and page-level improvements, which a writer then has to turn into pages.

Promptwatch's visitor analytics counts AI-referred visits and conversions on every plan. LLM Pulse lists conversions and revenue by AI source from Growth (€99). AthenaHQ connects GA4, and Semrush offers GA4 or Adobe data on Enterprise AIO. Otterly's site lists only a free AI referral traffic checker.

Is there anything cheaper than Otterly.AI?

Not among paid plans. Otterly Lite at €29 is the lowest entry here, and LLM Pulse Starter is €49 with weekly tracking. AthenaHQ's Essential tier is free, capped at 300 credits.

Does Otterly.AI have AI crawler logs?

Partly. Agent Analytics is on Standard (200k events a month) and up, though Otterly's llms.txt calls it a closed beta. IP verification of bots and a crawl-to-citation link are not listed. Promptwatch has both from Professional.