Agentic SEO Tools
All posts
By Agentic SEO Tools Teamalternatives

Scrunch AI alternatives that act, not just report: 6 tools scored (2026)

Six Scrunch AI alternatives scored on monitor, optimize, publish and measure, with plan limits and gaps taken from vendor pages we checked in November 2026.

Scrunch AI is built by people who think AI agents deserve their own version of your website. That idea is real. The Agent Experience Platform (AXP) serves token-light, AI-optimized versions of your pages to agents without changing what human visitors see, and the Agent Traffic product splits bot visits into training, indexing and retrieval. Scrunch's llms.txt now describes it as a Sitecore company. For a site that ranks tools by whether they act, it deserves a serious look.

The problem is what you can buy without a sales call. Scrunch has one self-serve plan. Core costs $250 a month and includes 125 unique prompts, 5,000 responses a month, one country, one language, one persona, five competitors, five user licenses, five site audits a month and a 7-day free trial. It tracks four LLMs: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Copilot. Claude, Gemini, Meta AI, Google AI Mode and Grok are Enterprise only. So are AXP itself, product-level shopping data, MCP access, the query API and Looker Studio. Query fan-outs are "Limited" on Core, and you get one page optimization a month.

Scrunch pricing page with the Core plan at $250 a month listing 125 unique prompts, 5,000 responses a month, 5 site audits, 1 brand workspace and 5 user licenses, next to a custom Enterprise plan that adds AXP Scrunch's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.

That's the pattern teams run into. The part of Scrunch that acts on your site sits on Enterprise, and Core is mostly a monitoring and recommendations plan with basic content generation. Its pricing and product pages (checked November 2026) don't list CMS publishing, AI-referred conversions or Search Console data at all. If what you want is a tool that turns a visibility gap into a published page and then proves the page worked, you need to look elsewhere.

Quick verdict

We scored every tool from 0 to 3 on four stages, using only what its pricing and product pages state. Monitor covers engines, allowance, location, frequency, fan-outs and personas. Optimize covers the action queue, refresh suggestions, site audits and claim checking. Publish means the tool writes content and gets it into a CMS. Measure covers crawler logs, whether they link to citations, AI-referred conversions and Search Console data. A 3 needs depth on a self-serve plan with a listed price. Enterprise-only features, or features whose plan we couldn't read, count for less.

The list order is our ranking, not a sum of the four numbers. It puts tools that act on a priced plan ahead of tools that mostly report, and it keeps enterprise-only products below the dedicated self-serve platforms. Where a tool's scores look out of step with its place, the section says why.

ToolMonitorOptimizePublishMeasure
Promptwatch (Business)3333
AthenaHQ2211
Goodie AI2212
Profound1111
Rankscale3202
LLM Pulse1212
Scrunch AI (reference)2212

Promptwatch is the one to trial first. It is the only tool here that scores full marks on all four stages from a self-serve plan, and it publishes to WordPress, Webflow and Framer. AthenaHQ suits teams whose main complaint is Scrunch's engine list. Goodie AI suits brands that want claims about them checked. Profound fits enterprises buying a broad marketing-agent program. Rankscale is the best monitor for the money but writes nothing. LLM Pulse is the cheapest way in if weekly data is enough.

Scrunch AI alternatives at a glance

ToolBest forStarting priceWhat it doesn't list
PromptwatchTeams that want tracking, crawler logs, conversions and published content in one project$95/mo (Essential), 7-day free trialA free plan; crawler logs and AEO articles start on Professional ($245)
AthenaHQTeams that need Gemini, Claude and AI Mode without EnterpriseFree Essential; Starter $295/moCrawler logs; query fan-outs; MCP
Goodie AIBrands that want claim checking and conversion reportingCore $295/mo, 7-day free trialCMS publishing; query fan-outs; REST API below Enterprise
ProfoundEnterprises buying a marketing-agent programFree 7-day trial; Enterprise customAny self-serve paid plan; API and exports on the trial
RankscaleTechnical teams that want many engines and hourly runs on a budgetPro €99/mo (Essentials €17/mo, yearly only)Content generation; personas; conversion reporting
LLM PulseSmall teams that want the lowest published priceStarter €49/mo, weekly trackingDaily runs on the base plans; CMS publishing; personas
Scrunch AI (reference)Sites that want to see and shape what AI agents readCore $250/mo, 7-day free trialGemini, Claude and AI Mode on Core; CMS publishing; AI-referred conversions

Sources: each vendor's pricing page and homepage captured November 6, 2026, plus product pages and llms.txt files read November 8, 2026. Rankscale and LLM Pulse showed euro prices to a visitor in the Netherlands.

1. Promptwatch: the full loop on a priced plan

Promptwatch scores 3 on every stage on Business ($579 a month). Professional ($245), which costs about the same as Scrunch Core, scores 2, 3, 2 and 3: state and city tracking, coordinate targeting and runs every 12, 6 or 1 hours start on Business, and Professional writes articles on demand rather than through the scheduled Content Agent. Essential ($95) has no crawler logs and no AEO articles, so at the entry price Scrunch Core includes bot traffic that Essential doesn't.

Here is what closes each Scrunch gap, with the plan you need:

  • Engines. Every paid plan can track any of the supported engines, including Gemini, Google AI Mode, Meta AI and Copilot through their real interfaces, and Claude, Grok, DeepSeek and Mistral through their APIs. There is no per-engine surcharge.
  • Publishing. AEO articles start on Professional (5 a month) and Business has 10. They go to WordPress through the official plugin, to Webflow or to Framer, as a draft or live. Business adds the automated Content Agent, which works from a publishing calendar and a monthly budget and either sends drafts to a review inbox or publishes them.
  • Crawler depth. Agent Analytics starts on Professional. It checks each bot against the operator's published IP ranges, shows a citation rate per page and explains crawl errors. Scrunch doesn't list any of that for its bot traffic.
  • Conversions and search data. Visitor analytics counts AI-referred visits and conversions on every plan. Search Insights puts Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster data beside it on every brand plan.
  • Agent access. A hosted MCP server with 110+ read and write tools and the REST API are on every paid plan. Looker Studio starts on Professional.
  • Claim checking. Brand Narrative is on every plan. Fact Check, which reads your own crawled pages to confirm or contradict a claim, is on Business.

Promptwatch content editor with a draft article on property taxes for non-EU buyers and an AI chat panel showing an applied, revertible edit that added an FAQ section Promptwatch content editor, from the Promptwatch changelog. Example project data.

The editor in the screenshot is where Promptwatch's act stage happens. A brief built from a tracked prompt, its fan-outs and up to five competitor URLs becomes a draft, and the AI chat panel makes edits you can revert. Once the page is live, the same project follows it through crawls, citations and visits, and underperformers come back as Action Board items or Content Refresh suggestions. Our explainer on what makes a platform agentic covers why that return path matters.

The weak spots: there is no free plan, only the 7-day trial on monthly billing and the free AI Visibility Report. Fact Check, ChatGPT Shopping and Ads Radar start on Business. Nothing in Promptwatch's documentation serves alternate pages to AI agents, so it doesn't replace AXP. Every paid plan has unlimited seats, against five licenses on Scrunch Core.

2. AthenaHQ: the engines Scrunch Core leaves out

AthenaHQ is the answer if Scrunch's engine list is the reason you're leaving. Starter costs $295 a month and lists 11 models: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral. That covers all five engines Scrunch keeps on Enterprise. It runs on 3,600 credits a month (one credit is one AI response) with unlimited topics, prompts and competitors inside that cap, a one-month rollover and unlimited users. A free Essential tier gives you 300 credits on five engines and the Ask Athena agent.

AthenaHQ pricing page with a free Essential tier, Starter at $295 a month with visibility across 11 models and a 1-month credit rollover, and a custom Enterprise plan listing the Athena Citation Engine AthenaHQ's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.

On the act side, Starter has on-page and off-page actions, a content optimization agent and "self-learning content improvement". Its Shopify integration can publish content. A GA4 integration ties visibility to traffic and conversions, and a Search Console integration puts SEO and AI search performance side by side.

Goodie scores a point higher on Measure, so why is AthenaHQ second? Because everything we scored for AthenaHQ sits on a plan we could read, at a listed price. Goodie's crawler analytics, claim checking and content tools had no legible tier on its pricing page. The limits are still real. The Athena Citation Engine (its autonomous content agent), personas and multi-region tracking are Enterprise only, Starter covers one country, and the API is a paid add-on with its price on request. Crawler logs, query fan-outs and an MCP server aren't listed on AthenaHQ's pricing or product pages (checked November 2026).

3. Goodie AI: claim checking and conversions

Goodie AI Core is $295 a month on monthly billing, and annual billing gives two months free. It includes five models (ChatGPT, AI Overview, Perplexity, AI Mode and Copilot), 110 prompts, one brand, two countries, two languages, daily tracking, 50 optimization actions and 30 prompt researches a month, a read-only MCP server, unlimited seats with AEO strategist support, and a 7-day free trial.

Its strongest stage is Optimize. Optimization Actions are ranked by estimated impact. Brand Command drafts brand facts from your site and documents, and once your team approves them, answers are checked against them and false claims are flagged. It also reads access logs for named AI bots, reports AI-referred sessions and conversions by model and landing page, and lists Google Analytics, Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools in every plan column.

Goodie Brand Command page headed "Know When AI Gets Your Brand Wrong", with a Narrative panel below tracking the claims a brand wants to own and which competitor holds them Goodie's Brand Command page, captured November 8, 2026.

For a Scrunch leaver the engine story is mixed. Core adds AI Mode, but Gemini only arrives on Pro at $999 a month, and Claude, Meta AI, DeepSeek and Grok appear only in the Enterprise column. Content Studio writes and refreshes pages, but no CMS publishing step is described. Query fan-outs aren't listed, and the REST API is Enterprise only.

4. Profound: acts, but only on a custom contract

Profound sells itself as an "AI Marketer" that researches, writes and reports. Its homepage describes agents that rewrite pages losing citations and stage them in your CMS, and its pricing grid lists Agent Analytics with integrations for Cloudflare, Fastly, Vercel, Netlify, AWS, Akamai, Google Cloud, Google Analytics and WordPress. On paper it acts.

Profound pricing page headed "Meet your AI Marketer" with a free Trial of 50 prompts run daily for 7 days on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews, next to a custom Enterprise plan tracking up to 9 answer engines Profound's pricing page, captured November 6, 2026.

In practice there is nothing to buy between a free trial and a custom deal. The Trial runs 50 prompts daily for 7 days on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews, with limited credits, one region, no history, no exports and no API. Enterprise is custom: up to nine answer engines, ChatGPT Shopping, the API, SSO and SOC 2. That is why every stage scores 1. Profound sits above Rankscale on this site because it writes and stages pages, which Rankscale doesn't do at all, and below AthenaHQ and Scrunch because none of it has a published price.

5. Rankscale: the strongest monitor, and it writes nothing

Rankscale is the best pure monitor on this list. Every plan tracks the same 17+ engines, scheduling runs from hourly to monthly on every plan, and query fan-outs come with probed domains, wins and losses. Pro is €99 a month for 1,200 credits (up to 4,800 answers), Pro+ €229, Growth €385, Enterprise €780, and Essentials is €17 a month on yearly billing only. Engines cost credits at different rates: 0.25 a run for ChatGPT, AI Mode, Perplexity and Gemini, 1 for DeepSeek, 2 for Claude.

Pro adds shopping analysis, ad analytics, a Looker Studio connector and AI Visits, a Cloudflare-only crawler view with a daily sync. Rankscale's own facts page says it "analyzes output but does not generate text or media itself", so its Publish score is 0. Personas and conversion reporting aren't listed, and SSO is on the custom plan only. A 7-day free Pro trial is available.

6. LLM Pulse: the cheapest start, on a weekly cadence

LLM Pulse Starter is €49 a month (€40.83 billed annually) for 50 prompts tracked weekly on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, AI Overviews and Gemini. Other engines are paid add-ons from €8 a month, with Claude at €25 on weekly Starter. Daily tracking is sold as separate plans with no trial. GEO Writer drafts content (3 tasks a month on Starter), and recommendations and GEO audits are on every plan. AI traffic with conversions starts on Growth (€99), crawler logs and the REST API on Scale (€299). The MCP server, with about 140 tools, and unlimited team members are on every plan. Its 14-day trial is twice as long as Promptwatch's. It sits last because at Starter it is mostly a weekly report with a few drafts a month, and CMS publishing and personas aren't listed.

Feature gaps, row by row

CapabilityPromptwatchScrunch AIAthenaHQGoodie AIRankscale
Gemini, Claude and AI Mode on the entry paid planAny supported engine, every paid planEnterprise onlyYes, StarterAI Mode on Core; Gemini on Pro; Claude EnterpriseYes, every plan
Query fan-outsYesLimited on CoreNot listedNot listedYes, every plan
State/city or coordinate targetingBusiness and upNot listedNot listedNot listedNot listed
Faster than dailyEvery 12, 6 or 1 hours, BusinessNot listedNot listedDaily; faster not listedHourly, every plan
Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn, Instagram reportsYesPartial ("Social" segment)Not listedNot listed as reportsNot listed as reports
Track a competitor's URLPage TrackerOwn pages; competitors not statedNot listedOwn pages; competitors not listedPartial (audits of any URL)
IP-verified bots and crawl-to-citation rateProfessional and upNot listedNot listedNot listedNot listed
AI-referred conversionsEvery planNot listedPartial (GA4)YesNot listed (GA4 beta for traffic)
Search Console and Bing dataEvery brand planNot listedSearch Console onlyYesSearch Console (beta)
Fact check against your own pagesBusiness and upNot listedEnterprise onlyYes (tier not legible)Not listed
CMS publishingWordPress, Webflow, Framer; automated on BusinessNot listedPartial (Shopify)Not listedNot listed
MCP serverEvery paid planEnterprise onlyNot listedEvery plan, read-onlyEvery plan
REST API on a self-serve planEvery paid planEnterprise onlyPaid add-onEnterprise onlyPro+ and up
Ads inside AI answersBusiness and upNot listedNot listedNot listedPro and up

Sources: vendor pricing pages and homepages captured November 6, 2026, product pages and llms.txt files read November 8, 2026. "Not listed" means not on that vendor's pricing or product pages we checked in November 2026; it doesn't prove the feature is absent.

Which rows matter depends on who is buying. A content team should start with the publishing row: of the five tools, only Promptwatch documents getting a page into WordPress, Webflow or Framer on a self-serve plan. A technical SEO team should read the crawler rows. Scrunch Core will show you which AI bots visited and which pages they read, but without IP verification or a citation rate per page you can't tell a spoofed bot from a real one, or an access problem from a content problem. Multi-market brands should look at location, where Scrunch Core and AthenaHQ Starter both stop at one country. Rankscale beats Promptwatch on hourly runs at €99 and on ad tracking below Business, and that's worth saying plainly.

Who should pick which

  • The work should end in a live page, with proof it was crawled, cited and clicked: Promptwatch, on Professional for crawler logs and articles, or Business for the automated Content Agent.
  • You mainly need Gemini, Claude and AI Mode without an Enterprise contract: AthenaHQ Starter.
  • You want AI claims checked against approved brand facts: Goodie AI, after confirming which tier includes Brand Command.
  • You're buying an enterprise marketing-agent program anyway: Profound, through its demo.
  • You want many engines and hourly runs, and will write content elsewhere: Rankscale.
  • You want the lowest price and weekly data is enough: LLM Pulse.
  • Stay on Scrunch AI if AXP is the reason you bought it and you're on Enterprise, or if ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews and Copilot cover your market and Core's bot traffic and five site audits are what you use. Nothing else on this list serves agent-optimized pages.

Our recommendation

Most teams outgrow Scrunch Core for one reason: it tells you where you're missing, then leaves the fix to you, and the parts that act sit on Enterprise. Promptwatch does the fix on a priced plan. The Content Generation Agent writes from a tracked prompt and the pages AI already cites, the article goes to your CMS, and Agent Analytics plus visitor analytics show whether bots read it, engines cited it and visitors converted. Load your Scrunch prompt set into the 7-day free trial on Professional, run both tools for the same week, and count what each one helped you ship. The full row-by-row table is in our Promptwatch vs Scrunch AI comparison.

FAQ

Which Scrunch AI alternative tracks Gemini and Claude without Enterprise?

Promptwatch lets every paid plan track any supported engine, AthenaHQ Starter lists both at $295, and Rankscale includes them on every plan, with Claude costing 2 credits a run. Goodie puts Gemini on Pro ($999) and Claude on Enterprise. LLM Pulse sells Claude as a €25 add-on on weekly Starter.

Does any alternative replace Scrunch's AXP?

Not on the pages we read. None of the tools here lists serving alternate, agent-optimized pages. If AXP is essential, stay on Scrunch Enterprise and add a tool for publishing and conversion tracking.

Do the alternatives include AI crawler logs?

Promptwatch has IP-verified crawler logs with a per-page citation rate from Professional. Rankscale has Cloudflare-based AI Visits from Pro, LLM Pulse has server-log data from Scale, Goodie lists AI Agent Analytics without a legible tier, and Profound lists Agent Analytics in its pricing grid. AthenaHQ manages crawler access but doesn't list visit logs.

Can I test an alternative without cancelling Scrunch?

Yes. Scrunch, Promptwatch, Goodie and Rankscale all offer 7-day trials, LLM Pulse offers 14 days and Profound's trial is free. Run the same prompts in both tools over the same week before you change anything.