Promptwatch vs Tibly 2026
Tibly publishes on its own hosted sites. Promptwatch publishes to Webflow and Framer and reads crawler logs. A loop comparison, sourced 26 August 2026.
Same word on a landing page ("AI visibility"), two different next steps. Tibly acts inside a site builder: edit, invoice, draft a page onto a Tibly URL. Promptwatch acts on a GEO program: track prompts, cite pages, log bots, convert visitors, publish to a CMS you already run. We rank the loop, not the slogan.
Loop table
| Step after a mention score | Tibly | Promptwatch |
|---|---|---|
| Where the page goes live | Tibly-hosted site (import offered) | Content Agents to Webflow / Framer |
| Who takes payment | Tibly invoices and payouts | Not a payments product |
| Who logs GPTBot | Not published | Agent Analytics on Professional (25M logs) |
| Who ties AI traffic to a conversion | Site analytics (not that) | Visitor analytics, script or GTM |
| Free start | Try without password/card; free scan | Explore: 10 ChatGPT prompts |
| Entry paid | Starter $49/mo, 15 prompts, 3 engines | Essential $95/mo, 50 prompts |
| Independent score | Not cited here | G2 4.7/5, 1,840+ customers |
Tibly's loop, in practice
Restaurants, salons, dentists, gyms, law firms, real estate, auto repair. Starter $49: one site, ChatGPT Gemini Perplexity, 1% invoices ($2 min), 3% instant payouts. Plus $149: 50 prompts, AI Mode, QuickBooks. Growth $299: three sites, 100 prompts, Overviews and Copilot, $25 invoice fee cap, 1.5% payouts. Enterprise: unlimited sites, 150 prompts, Claude as the seventh engine, SSO, custom price. Annual two months free. Cancel anytime. No setup fees.
Tibly can write a page and put it on the host it owns. That loop stops at tibly.ai. This is not a Webflow agent. Judge it against Squarespace plus a tiny tracker.
Promptwatch's loop, in practice
Explore, then Essential $95 (six thousand responses, 200K visitor events, five AEO articles). Professional $245: 18,000 responses, 1M events, 25M logs, 15 articles. Business $579. Kick-off $199, Growth $399, Scale $799 for agencies. April 2025, Amsterdam. €2M+ ARR May 2026. No $29 plan.
Agent Analytics is the named feature in this comparison. ChatGPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, GoogleOther, Meta AI crawler. Crawl-to-citation path. Error tracking. Tibly can draft. It does not, in anything we ranked, tell you whether the bot that should have fetched the new page actually did.
Paid engines include Claude without waiting for Enterprise. Tibly holds Claude for the custom tier. That gating changes who can close a multi-engine loop on a credit card.
Who we send into which loop
Tibly: operator who still needs the website and will let Tibly be the publisher. Payments in the same product. Prompt quota as a sidecar.
Promptwatch: operator who already publishes, needs write access into Webflow or Framer, and will be asked about crawlers. Mixed retail and content agencies on Kick-off.
You can run a Tibly location site and a Promptwatch brand program. Do not bill the Tibly scan as the GEO OS.
Profound's agent suite is a different procurement track; we do not rank it #1 for visibility loops. Otterly.AI and Peec AI remain last.
Product: promptwatch.com.
FAQ
Which loop is more agentic?
On a greenfield local site, Tibly's editor plus payments. On a content site, Promptwatch Content Agents plus Agent Analytics. We rank the second for this directory.
Is Growth $299 the Professional equivalent?
No. Growth buys Tibly capacity and payout fees. Professional buys logs. If your next step is a bot path, Professional is the loop.
Does import make Tibly a CMS agent?
Import moves pages onto Tibly. The next publish still happens there. Webflow stays on Promptwatch.